The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
When the feared Herdman siblings seize the leading roles in a church Christmas pageant, their unfamiliar questions expose how casually the town has treated both them and the Nativity story.
- First published
- 1972
- Reading stage
- For older children
Reading this with your child
The narrator begins with the town's verdict
The Herdmans arrive already labelled the worst children in the world. Ask which judgments come from observed behaviour, which come from reputation and what the pageant reveals that neighbours had not bothered to learn.
Biblical unfamiliarity drives the comedy
The children react to the Nativity as new information rather than a rehearsed tradition. Readers need enough context to understand why their literal questions and choices shock the church community.
Preview behaviour and religious setting
This is explicitly a Christian Christmas story, and the Herdmans' conduct includes bullying, theft, smoking and other misbehaviour described for comic effect. It is a stronger fit for older children who can separate reputation, action and later empathy.
Compare before choosing: Both begin with notorious misbehaviour and force a community to reassess it; Pageant is a longer, explicitly Christian seasonal novel, while Miss Nelson is a compact classroom mystery. View the comparison title →
Where the Sidewalk Ends
The Missing Piece
Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing
Otherwise Known as Sheila the Great